Evaluation form, All papers submitted to Modelica'2005 ------------------------

Evaluation on a scale 1-5, 1=bad, 2=acceptable, 3=OK, 4=Good, 5=Excellent

A: Scientific aspects - are there new results? 1-5 B: Clarity, easy to read, English language: 1-5 C: Importance to the Modelica effort 1-5 D: Validation- Have been implemented, used, etc? 1-5

Overall 1-5, where: 1=reject, 2=poster, 3=possible paper accept, 4=paper accept, 5=Excellent paper accept

NOTE: Overall is YOUR decision, it does not have to be a mean value of the other figures

Reviewer's main assignments are listed below each title.

The numbers (3) should be replaced by your values!

-----------------------

1. Kessenko - Dynamics of Rolling Bodies 1 Otter, Hilding

A, new results: 3 B: clarity, 3 C: Importance 3 D: Used,impl 3

Overall 3

Comment to committe:

Comment to author:

(OTHER PAPERS HERE ...)